Where the implementations differ
Every row more than one implementation states, sorted by ratio, widest first. A difference is not an error. Competent teams rendering one method against different flow lists will differ, and most of these are modelling choices; the widest are worth a conversation, not a correction.
Published says what this list did about the row: `agreed` where they stated one number, `sole` where only one did, and nothing at all where the disagreement went to a queue instead.
| Flow | Category | Place | European Commission — JRC | GreenDelta | ecoinvent Centre | Apart | Published |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Vanadium(5+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,708.278576 | 1,708.278576 | 1,708.278576 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Molybdenum(6+)
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.344601 | 0.344601 | 0.344601 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Zinc(2+)
Environmental → Water → Ocean
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1.3051e-17 | — | 1.3051e-17 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Selenium(4+)
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 30.200339 | 30.200339 | 30.200339 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Beryllium(2+)
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,626.068806 | 1,626.068806 | 1,626.068806 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Barium(2+)
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,285.034233 | 1,285.034233 | 1,285.034233 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Lead(2+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 27.702155 | 27.702155 | 27.702155 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Aluminium(3+)
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 2,002.745979 | 2,002.745979 | 2,002.745979 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Copper, ion
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | — | 17.00696 | 17.00696 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
adopted |
|
Mercury(2+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 15,871.616497 | 15,871.616497 | 15,871.616497 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Copper, ion
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | — | 17.070594 | 17.070594 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
adopted |
|
Selenium(4+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 30.139594 | 30.139594 | 30.139594 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Barium(2+)
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 3,697.562483 | 3,697.562483 | 3,697.562483 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Cadmium(2+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 237,902.712213 | 237,902.712213 | 237,902.712213 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Strontium(2+)
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 18,073.409791 | 18,073.409791 | 18,073.409791 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Cobalt(2+)
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 2,014.507718 | 2,014.507718 | 2,014.507718 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Beryllium(2+)
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,626.068806 | 1,626.068806 | 1,626.068806 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Barium(2+)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,283.954064 | 1,283.954064 | 1,283.954064 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Molybdenum(6+)
Environmental → Ground → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.494285 | 0.494285 | 0.494285 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
GreenDelta higher
|
agreed |
|
Thallium(1+)
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1,443.813269 | 1,443.813269 | 1,443.813269 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Copper
Environmental → Ground → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 24.533951 | — | 24.533951 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
European Commission — JRC higher
|
agreed |
|
Copper
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 17.070594 | — | 17.070594 |
1.0000×
within tolerance
ecoinvent Centre higher
|
agreed |
|
Silver(1+)
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 64,156.898518 | 64,156.898518 | 64,156.898518 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Tungsten
Environmental → Water → Unconfined aquifer
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | — | 80.527 | 80.527 |
1.0000×
identical
|
restated |
|
Sodium Chlorate
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 4.1903 | — | 4.1903 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Ammonia
Environmental → Ground → Industrial
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | — | 30.109 | 30.109 |
1.0000×
identical
|
restated |
|
Lead(2+)
Environmental → Water → Ocean
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1.8864e-21 | 1.8864e-21 | 1.8864e-21 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Aluminium Phosphide
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 2.2904e+06 | — | 2.2904e+06 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Thallium(1+)
Environmental → Ground → Agricultural
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 2,074.525969 | — | 2,074.525969 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Ground → Industrial
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | — | 1.2573 | 1.2573 |
1.0000×
identical
|
restated |
|
potassium hydrogencarbonate
Environmental → Ground → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1.9868 | — | 1.9868 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Sodium borohydride
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 3.0746 | — | 3.0746 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Mercury(2+)
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 33,175.97306 | 33,175.97306 | 33,175.97306 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Silicon
Environmental → Ground → Agricultural
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.005076 | 0.005076 | 0.005076 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Potassium Chloride
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1.0618 | — | 1.0618 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Sodium borohydride
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 3.2721 | 3.2721 | 3.2721 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Carbon Monoxide (fossil)
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.022833 | 0.022833 | 0.022833 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Chlorate
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 4.7248 | 4.7248 | 4.7248 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Chlorate
Environmental → Water → Ocean
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 1.3453e-19 | — | 1.3453e-19 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.34838 | 0.34838 | — |
1.0000×
identical
|
sole |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.34865 | 0.34865 | — |
1.0000×
identical
|
sole |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 20.361 | 20.361 | 20.361 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 20.361 | 20.361 | 20.361 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluoride(1-)
Environmental → Water → Ocean
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.044974 | 0.044974 | 0.044974 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluorine
Environmental → Air → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.34838 | 0.34838 | 0.34838 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluorine
Environmental → Air → Ground level → Urban (>1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.34865 | 0.34865 | 0.34865 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluorine
Environmental → Air → Medium stack, <150 meters → Rural (<1000 people/square mile)
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 0.3481 | 0.3481 | 0.3481 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Fluorine
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 20.361 | 20.361 | 20.361 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Hydrogen Peroxide
Environmental → Water → Surface water
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 58.72 | 58.72 | 58.72 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |
|
Hydrogen Peroxide
Environmental → Water → Unknown
|
Ecotoxicity, freshwater_inorganics
EF 3.1
|
— | 58.72 | — | 58.72 |
1.0000×
identical
|
agreed |