Methyl Benzoate
b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c
Identity
- Substance
- fo-d2ca5e3273d36eb6 Neutral molecule
- Source
- EF 3.1
- Unit
- kg
- Context
- Environmental → Water → Long-term
- CAS
- 93-58-3
- EC
- 202-259-7
Context
- Dimension
- Environmental
- Media
- Water
- Water body
- Long-term
Alternative labels
4- Benzoic acid, methyl ester
- Methyl benzenecarboxylate
- Clorius
- Niobe oil
Source lists
1| List | Version | Source flow | Name there | Why this flow |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EF | 3.1 | b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c | methyl benzoate | The consensus list is built from this one, so this row is the flow itself rather than something matched to it. |
Concept associations
1| Source list | Source flow | Name there | Compartment there | Match | Conversion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EF 3.1 | b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c | methyl benzoate | Emissions/Emissions to water/Emissions to water, unspecified (long-term) | exactMatch | — |
Characterisation factors
4- consensus-flow-list 2 (0 non-zero)
- European Commission — JRC 2 (0 non-zero)
Every implementation that says anything about this flow. Published as is what this list did with the row: where more than one implementation states a number and they agree it publishes it as agreed; where only one speaks, as sole; where they disagree it publishes nothing and asks.
| Method | Implementation | Category | Place | Factor | Published as |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EF 3.1 | European Commission — JRC | Ecotoxicity, freshwater | — | 0 | — |
| EF 3.1 | consensus-flow-list | Ecotoxicity, freshwater | — | 0 | sole |
| EF 3.1 | European Commission — JRC | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics | — | 0 | — |
| EF 3.1 | consensus-flow-list | Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics | — | 0 | sole |
History
The change log and the PROV-O trail (2 consensus changes)
These are the heaviest sections of this page and the least often read, so the page does not pay for them until you ask.
Full record
Flow JSON
{
"altLabel": [
{
"@value": "Benzoic acid, methyl ester",
"@language": "en",
"source": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "chebi_altlabels",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775",
"EF 3.1"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi synonym match"
}
},
{
"@value": "Methyl benzenecarboxylate",
"@language": "en",
"source": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "chebi_altlabels",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775",
"EF 3.1"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi synonym match"
}
},
{
"@value": "Clorius",
"@language": "en",
"source": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "consensus_match",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CAS:93-58-3",
"https://commonchemistry.cas.org/detail?cas_rn=93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "common chemistry CAS lookup"
}
},
{
"@value": "Niobe oil",
"@language": "en",
"source": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "consensus_match",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CAS:93-58-3",
"https://commonchemistry.cas.org/detail?cas_rn=93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "common chemistry CAS lookup"
}
}
],
"properties": {
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/molecular_formula": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/molecular_formula",
"@value": [
"C8H8O2"
],
"attested_by": {
"C8H8O2": [
"enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"enrich_references.pubchem_semantic",
"rdkit_post_consensus"
]
},
"rdfs:label": "Molecular formula",
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.basic_property_values.generalized_empirical_formula"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.props.Molecular Formula"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
]
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/smiles_string": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/smiles_string",
"rdfs:label": "SMILES",
"@value": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
],
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "opsin_iupac",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"Methyl Benzoate"
]
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
],
"attested_by": {
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1": [
"opsin_iupac",
"rdkit_post_consensus"
]
}
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/inchi2d_string": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/inchi2d_string",
"rdfs:label": "InChI",
"@value": [
"InChI=1S/C8H8O2/c1-10-8(9)7-5-3-2-4-6-7/h2-6H,1H3"
],
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "opsin_iupac",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"Methyl Benzoate"
]
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
],
"attested_by": {
"InChI=1S/C8H8O2/c1-10-8(9)7-5-3-2-4-6-7/h2-6H,1H3": [
"opsin_iupac",
"rdkit_post_consensus"
]
}
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/inchi2d_key_string": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/inchi2d_key_string",
"@value": [
"QPJVMBTYPHYUOC-UHFFFAOYSA-N"
],
"attested_by": {
"QPJVMBTYPHYUOC-UHFFFAOYSA-N": [
"enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"enrich_references.pubchem_semantic",
"rdkit_post_consensus"
]
},
"rdfs:label": "InChIKey",
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.basic_property_values.inchi_key_string"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.props.InChIKey"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
]
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/molecular_mass": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/molecular_mass",
"@value": [
136.15
],
"attested_by": {
"136.15": [
"enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"rdkit_post_consensus"
]
},
"rdfs:label": "Molecular mass",
"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt/hasUnit": "https://vocab.brightway.one/units/unit/GM-PER-MOL",
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.basic_property_values.mass"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
]
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/monoisotopic_mass": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/monoisotopic_mass",
"@value": [
136.052429,
136.05243
],
"attested_by": {
"136.05243": [
"enrich_references.chebi_semantic"
],
"136.052429": [
"rdkit_post_consensus",
"rdkit_pre_consensus"
]
},
"rdfs:label": "Monoisotopic mass",
"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt/hasUnit": "https://vocab.brightway.one/units/unit/GM-PER-MOL",
"provenance": [
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.basic_property_values.monoisotopic_mass"
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_pre_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)C1=CC=CC=C1"
]
},
{
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "rdkit_post_consensus",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"COC(=O)c1ccccc1"
]
}
]
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/elemental_charge": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/elemental_charge",
"@value": [
0
],
"attested_by": {
"0": [
"enrich_references.chebi_semantic"
]
},
"rdfs:label": "Elemental charge",
"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt/hasUnit": "https://vocab.brightway.one/units/unit/NUM",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_semantic",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.basic_property_values.charge"
}
},
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/IUPAC_name": {
"@id": "https://w3id.org/chemrof/IUPAC_name",
"rdfs:label": "IUPAC name",
"@value": [
"Methyl Benzoate"
],
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "opsin_iupac",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"Methyl Benzoate"
]
},
"attested_by": {
"Methyl Benzoate": [
"opsin_iupac"
]
}
}
},
"references": [
{
"@id": "http://jglobal.jst.go.jp/en/redirect?Nikkaji_No=J9.149I",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://chem.echa.europa.eu/100.002.055",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://chemicalsafety.ilo.org/dyn/icsc/showcard.display?p_card_id=1187",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://commonchemistry.cas.org/detail?cas_rn=93-58-3",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://comptox.epa.gov/dashboard/DTXSID5025572",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://dtp.cancer.gov/dtpstandard/servlet/dwindex?searchtype=NSC&outputformat=html&searchlist=9394",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methyl_benzoate",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://gsrs.ncats.nih.gov/ginas/app/beta/substances/6618K1VJ9T",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://hmdb.ca/metabolites/HMDB0033968",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://metacyc.org/compound?orgid=META&id=CPD-6441",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/7150",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_compound",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.by_cas[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/substance/?source=niaid&sourceid=018029",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10852939",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/chebi/searchId.do?chebiId=CHEBI:72775",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_id_link",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.id"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/chembl/explore/compound/CHEMBL16435",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.femaflavor.org/flavor-library/methyl-benzoate",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.kegg.jp/entry/C20645",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.metabolomicsworkbench.org/data/StructureData.php?RegNo=46315",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q417328",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.pubchem_identifier_url",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"CID:7150;CAS:93-58-3"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "pubchem.identifiers[93-58-3]"
}
},
{
"@id": "reaxys:1072099",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_xrefs",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.xrefs_urls"
}
}
],
"prefLabel": [
{
"@value": "Methyl Benzoate",
"@language": "en",
"source": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "bootstrap_labels",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"EF 3.1"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "legacy name field"
}
}
],
"@type": [
"https://w3id.org/chemrof/NeutralMolecule"
],
"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition": [
{
"@value": "A benzoate ester obtained by condensation of benzoic acid and methanol.",
"@language": "en",
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "enrich_references.chebi_definition",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/CHEBI_72775"
],
"prov:wasDerivedFrom": "chebi.definition"
}
}
],
"uuid": "b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c",
"identifier": "b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c",
"source": "EF 3.1",
"cas_numbers": [
"93-58-3"
],
"ec_numbers": [
"202-259-7"
],
"context": {
"dimension": "Environmental",
"media": "Water",
"water_body": "Long-term"
},
"synonyms": [],
"lcia_methods": [
{
"method_uuid": "05316e7a-b254-4bea-9cf0-6bf33eb5c630",
"name": "Ecotoxicity, freshwater",
"methodology": "Environmental Footprint",
"impact_category": "Aquatic eco-toxicity",
"impact_indicator": "Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) ",
"characterization_factor": 0.0
},
{
"method_uuid": "fd530f00-9325-424a-92ef-aaac67922fd9",
"name": "Ecotoxicity, freshwater_organics",
"methodology": "Environmental Footprint",
"impact_category": "Aquatic eco-toxicity",
"impact_indicator": "Comparative Toxic Unit for ecosystems (CTUe) ",
"characterization_factor": 0.0
}
],
"unit": "kg",
"input_datasets": [
"EF 3.1"
],
"context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-wate-lote",
"unit_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/units/unit/KiloGM",
"flow_object_id": "fo-d2ca5e3273d36eb6",
"concept_associations": [
{
"@type": "xkos:ConceptAssociation",
"xkos:sourceConcept": {
"@id": "https://vocab.brightway.one/ef/3.1/flow/b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c",
"skos:prefLabel": "methyl benzoate",
"context": "Emissions/Emissions to water/Emissions to water, unspecified (long-term)",
"qudt:hasUnit": {
"@id": "https://vocab.brightway.one/units/unit/KiloGM"
},
"skos:exactMatch": {
"@id": "https://vocab.brightway.dev/elementary-flows/b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c"
}
},
"xkos:targetConcept": {
"@id": "https://vocab.brightway.dev/elementary-flows/b2bb037c-c8a6-427d-8b82-1c4caadb2f6c"
},
"provenance": {
"prov:wasGeneratedBy": "build_concept_associations",
"prov:wasAttributedTo": "consensus-flow-list",
"prov:hadPrimarySource": [
"https://eplca.jrc.ec.europa.eu/permalink/EF3_1/EF-v3.1.zip"
]
}
}
],
"_sources": {
"prefLabel": "normalize_name_case",
"name": "bootstrap_labels",
"synonyms": "bootstrap_labels",
"context": "default_context_mapping",
"context_iri": "default_context_mapping",
"unit_iri": "unit_normalization",
"properties": "normalise_property_values",
"skos_definition": "enrich_references",
"references": "enrich_references",
"altLabel": "strip_catalogue_altlabels",
"cas_match_labels": "consensus_match",
"concept_associations": "carry_associations_onto_flows",
"types": "link_flows_to_their_substance"
},
"cas_match_labels": {
"93-58-3": "exactMatch"
},
"_transformed": true,
"_provided": {
"name": "methyl benzoate",
"synonyms": [
"organic",
"methylbenzoate"
],
"context": [
"Emissions",
"Emissions to water",
"Emissions to water, unspecified (long-term)"
],
"cas_numbers": [
"93-58-3"
],
"ec_numbers": [
"202-259-7"
],
"unit": "kg"
}
}
Something wrong here?
A flow can be wrong in three ways, and they are decided differently. Pick the one that matches what you are looking at.
- A row from my list should not reach this flow
- This flow is not that chemical
- The compartment or the unit is wrong
- One of these characterisation factors cannot be this substance's
You do not need to run a build or clone anything. Name the row and say what your evidence is; the measurement is done for you. How contributing works