Brightway Flows 1.1.0
GitHub
Present in 2 source lists

Each list resolved it independently. Where they disagree, that is a conflict.

ecoinvent 3.12

created
Name
Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)
Context
natural resource → land
Unit
m2.a
CAS
—
EC
—
Method
flow_object_creation
Substance
fo-7ed0ff48f3995233
Target flow
6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b
Everything this outcome recorded
{
  "source_uuid": "81e07a67-28e0-4392-a553-d86e54a9b8a9",
  "source_name": "Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)",
  "source_context": [
    "natural resource",
    "land"
  ],
  "source_context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/laus-occu",
  "source_unit": "m2.a",
  "source_cas": "",
  "source_ec": "",
  "flow_object_id": "fo-7ed0ff48f3995233",
  "flow_object_label": "Cropland, reduced tillage",
  "flow_object_cas": [],
  "flow_object_ec": [],
  "new_elementary_flow_id": "6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b",
  "minted_flow_object": true,
  "identity_is_name_only": true,
  "provenance": {
    "prov:wasGeneratedBy": "merge_ecoinvent",
    "prov:wasAttributedTo": "brightway-flows",
    "prov:hadPrimarySource": [
      "ecoinvent:3.12:81e07a67-28e0-4392-a553-d86e54a9b8a9",
      "Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)",
      ""
    ],
    "prov:wasDerivedFrom": "flow_object_creation:no-flow-object-candidate"
  },
  "has_unit_mismatch": false,
  "unit_decision": {
    "units": [
      "m2.a"
    ],
    "declared": "m2.a",
    "decided_by": "unit_table"
  }
}

ecoinvent 3.8

algorithm
Name
Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)
Context
natural resource → land
Unit
m2.a
CAS
—
EC
—
Basis
land_class occupation/cropland/tillage=reduced
Method
algorithm
Substance
fo-7ed0ff48f3995233
Target flow
6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b

What it could have been

1 flow between them, 1 of them eligible after the dimension and media filter.

Score Name Unit Context LCIA Flow
0 Cropland, reduced tillage m2.a Land Use → Occupation 0 6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b
Everything this outcome recorded
{
  "source_uuid": "81e07a67-28e0-4392-a553-d86e54a9b8a9",
  "source_name": "Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)",
  "source_context": [
    "natural resource",
    "land"
  ],
  "source_context_normalized": [
    "Land Use",
    "Occupation"
  ],
  "source_context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/laus-occu",
  "source_unit": "m2.a",
  "source_cas": "",
  "source_ec": "",
  "flow_object_id": "fo-7ed0ff48f3995233",
  "target_name": "Cropland, reduced tillage",
  "target_elementary_flow_id": "6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b",
  "target_context": [
    "Land Use",
    "Occupation"
  ],
  "target_unit": "m2.a",
  "basis": "land_class",
  "basis_value": "occupation/cropland/tillage=reduced",
  "selector_reason": "exact-context-iri-match",
  "matching_method": "algorithm",
  "algorithm_details": {
    "flow_object_candidate_count": 1,
    "elementary_candidate_count": 1,
    "eligible_candidate_count": 1,
    "filtered_out_context_mismatch_count": 0,
    "required_dimension": "Land Use",
    "required_media": "Occupation",
    "selector_model": "exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto",
    "top_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b",
        "score": 0,
        "unit_exact": false,
        "context_overlap": 0,
        "context_penalty": 0,
        "context_iri_exact": true,
        "unit": "m2.a",
        "context": [
          "Land Use",
          "Occupation"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/laus-occu"
      }
    ],
    "scored_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "6c625a59de68bc6b61606555d8d9d53120bd541b",
        "score": 0,
        "unit_exact": false,
        "context_overlap": 0,
        "context_penalty": 0,
        "context_iri_exact": true,
        "unit": "m2.a",
        "context": [
          "Land Use",
          "Occupation"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/laus-occu"
      }
    ],
    "winning_score": null,
    "tie_on_top_score": false,
    "source_context_original": [
      "natural resource",
      "land"
    ],
    "source_context_normalized": [
      "Land Use",
      "Occupation"
    ],
    "source_context_used_for_matching": [
      "Land Use",
      "Occupation"
    ],
    "source_context_matching_basis": "normalized"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "prov:wasGeneratedBy": "merge_ecoinvent",
    "prov:wasAttributedTo": "brightway-flows",
    "prov:hadPrimarySource": [
      "ecoinvent:3.8:81e07a67-28e0-4392-a553-d86e54a9b8a9",
      "Occupation, Arable, Reduced Tillage (obsolete)",
      "",
      "algorithm.lookup_order=cas>ec>label",
      "algorithm.basis=land_class:occupation/cropland/tillage=reduced",
      "algorithm.flow_object_candidates=1",
      "algorithm.elementary_candidates=1",
      "algorithm.selector_reason=exact-context-iri-match",
      "algorithm.score_rule=exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto"
    ],
    "prov:wasDerivedFrom": "algorithmic_fallback:lookup_order(cas>ec>label);basis(land_class:occupation/cropland/tillage=reduced);flow_object_candidates(1);elementary_candidates(1);selector(exact-context-iri-match);exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto"
  },
  "conversion_factor": 1.0,
  "conversion_comment": "A land occupation is an area held in a use for a time, and ecoinvent says so everywhere else: of the sixty flows it files in `natural resource / land` whose name begins `Occupation,`, fifty-seven are in m2*a and these three are in m2 -- the same fifty-seven and the same three in every registered release, 3.8 through 3.12. EF 3.1 draws no distinction either; every land-occupation flow it carries is in m2*a. So the unit on these three is a slip rather than a different way of measuring the land, and publishing them in m2 would put an area beside fifty-seven area-times and leave a reader to notice.\n\necoinvent states what it means by them itself: every one of its correspondence tables to EF 3.1 -- 3.9.1, 3.10.1, 3.11 and the 3.8 chain composed here -- maps this flow onto EF's m2*a `arable` with a factor of 1.0, commented `Assumed conversion based on land use through an entire year`. The amount is one year's occupation. That is a modelling choice and not a measurement, which is why this project refuses to inherit it silently from a table; asserted here, with the reasoning attached, it is this project's own statement.\n\nThe factor is 1.0 and is stated rather than left out for the reason the `m3` to `sm3` rewrite states its own: `units.json` reads m2 as an area and m2*a as an area-time, so it implies nothing between them, and the number is what keeps the rewrite from silently reinterpreting the vendor's amounts. It is the only conversion in this project that crosses a time dimension.\n\nUntil #111 these three rows were mapped onto EF 3.1's unqualified `arable`, carrying this same factor on the mapping, and the tillage regime was lost. The mapping is declined now and the flow is published under its own name, so the factor moves onto the row it was always about."
}

Keyboard

?
Show or hide this map
/
Focus search
Esc
Close