Brightway Flows 1.1.0
GitHub
Present in 2 source lists

Each list resolved it independently. Where they disagree, that is a conflict.

ecoinvent 3.12

algorithm
Name
Manganese(2+)
Context
soil → industrial
Unit
kg
CAS
16397-91-4
EC
—
Basis
cas 16397-91-4
Method
algorithm
Substance
fo-80b64837f895a1ee
Target flow
e35b595632ce93b0e5640d6b49fe75837491b4f2

What it could have been

3 flows between them, 3 of them eligible after the dimension and media filter, 10 removed because the context did not agree, and 3 tied on the winning score of 3.

Score Name Unit Context LCIA Flow
3 tied Manganese(2+) kg Environmental → Ground → Unknown 2 053bf01c-9207-4ecb-8f23-d6adbf9c6ce2
3 tied Manganese(2+) kg Environmental → Ground → Non-agricultural 2 21a70472-6abb-4d7c-a94c-aee276e7bef3
3 tied Manganese(2+) kg Environmental → Ground → Agricultural 2 f8e1446b-38f8-4b47-b9ce-1b0415b95567
Everything this outcome recorded
{
  "source_uuid": "9c706cff-cb82-4207-a589-95896e04dc08",
  "source_name": "Manganese(2+)",
  "source_context": [
    "soil",
    "industrial"
  ],
  "source_context_normalized": [
    "Environmental",
    "Ground",
    "Industrial"
  ],
  "source_context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-indu",
  "source_unit": "kg",
  "source_cas": "16397-91-4",
  "source_ec": "",
  "flow_object_id": "fo-80b64837f895a1ee",
  "target_name": "Manganese(2+)",
  "target_elementary_flow_id": "e35b595632ce93b0e5640d6b49fe75837491b4f2",
  "target_context": [
    "Environmental",
    "Ground",
    "Industrial"
  ],
  "target_unit": "kg",
  "basis": "cas",
  "basis_value": "16397-91-4",
  "selector_reason": "new-elementary-flow-created",
  "matching_method": "algorithm",
  "algorithm_details": {
    "flow_object_candidate_count": 1,
    "elementary_candidate_count": 13,
    "eligible_candidate_count": 3,
    "filtered_out_context_mismatch_count": 10,
    "required_dimension": "Environmental",
    "required_media": "Ground",
    "selector_model": "exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto",
    "top_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "053bf01c-9207-4ecb-8f23-d6adbf9c6ce2",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Unknown"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-unkn"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "21a70472-6abb-4d7c-a94c-aee276e7bef3",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Non-agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-noag"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "f8e1446b-38f8-4b47-b9ce-1b0415b95567",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-agri"
      }
    ],
    "scored_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "053bf01c-9207-4ecb-8f23-d6adbf9c6ce2",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Unknown"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-unkn"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "21a70472-6abb-4d7c-a94c-aee276e7bef3",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Non-agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-noag"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "f8e1446b-38f8-4b47-b9ce-1b0415b95567",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-agri"
      }
    ],
    "winning_score": 3,
    "tie_on_top_score": true,
    "source_context_original": [
      "soil",
      "industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_normalized": [
      "Environmental",
      "Ground",
      "Industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_used_for_matching": [
      "Environmental",
      "Ground",
      "Industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_matching_basis": "normalized"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "prov:wasGeneratedBy": "merge_ecoinvent",
    "prov:wasAttributedTo": "brightway-flows",
    "prov:hadPrimarySource": [
      "ecoinvent:3.12:9c706cff-cb82-4207-a589-95896e04dc08",
      "Manganese(2+)",
      "",
      "algorithm.lookup_order=cas>ec>label",
      "algorithm.basis=cas:16397-91-4",
      "algorithm.flow_object_candidates=1",
      "algorithm.elementary_candidates=13",
      "algorithm.selector_reason=new-elementary-flow-created",
      "algorithm.score_rule=exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto",
      "algorithm.winning_score=3",
      "algorithm.tie_on_top_score=true"
    ],
    "prov:wasDerivedFrom": "algorithmic_fallback:lookup_order(cas>ec>label);basis(cas:16397-91-4);flow_object_candidates(1);elementary_candidates(13);selector(new-elementary-flow-created);exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto"
  }
}

ecoinvent 3.8

algorithm
Name
Manganese
Context
soil → industrial
Unit
kg
CAS
7439-96-5
EC
231-105-1
Basis
cas 7439-96-5
Method
algorithm
Substance
fo-399a338738afcc79
Target flow
5d8487d437a6cb8bc0aaaa7f6ab891dd8a5c8a40

What it could have been

4 flows between them, 4 of them eligible after the dimension and media filter, 12 removed because the context did not agree, and 4 tied on the winning score of 3.

Score Name Unit Context LCIA Flow
3 tied Manganese kg Environmental → Ground → Agricultural 2 08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc5-0050c2490048
3 tied Manganese kg Environmental → Ground → Unknown 2 08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc6-0050c2490048
3 tied Manganese kg Environmental → Ground → Non-agricultural 2 08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bcd-0050c2490048
3 tied Manganese kg Environmental → Ground → Silvicultural 0 f5bf83404ecd4beadee0049c91f703a1fa85921c
Everything this outcome recorded
{
  "source_uuid": "9c706cff-cb82-4207-a589-95896e04dc08",
  "source_name": "Manganese",
  "source_context": [
    "soil",
    "industrial"
  ],
  "source_context_normalized": [
    "Environmental",
    "Ground",
    "Industrial"
  ],
  "source_context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-indu",
  "source_unit": "kg",
  "source_cas": "7439-96-5",
  "source_ec": "231-105-1",
  "flow_object_id": "fo-399a338738afcc79",
  "target_name": "Manganese",
  "target_elementary_flow_id": "5d8487d437a6cb8bc0aaaa7f6ab891dd8a5c8a40",
  "target_context": [
    "Environmental",
    "Ground",
    "Industrial"
  ],
  "target_unit": "kg",
  "basis": "cas",
  "basis_value": "7439-96-5",
  "selector_reason": "new-elementary-flow-created",
  "matching_method": "algorithm",
  "algorithm_details": {
    "flow_object_candidate_count": 1,
    "elementary_candidate_count": 16,
    "eligible_candidate_count": 4,
    "filtered_out_context_mismatch_count": 12,
    "required_dimension": "Environmental",
    "required_media": "Ground",
    "selector_model": "exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto",
    "top_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc5-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-agri"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc6-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Unknown"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-unkn"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bcd-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Non-agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-noag"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "f5bf83404ecd4beadee0049c91f703a1fa85921c",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Silvicultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-silv"
      }
    ],
    "scored_candidates": [
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc5-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-agri"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bc6-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Unknown"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-unkn"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "08a91e70-3ddc-11dd-9bcd-0050c2490048",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Non-agricultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-noag"
      },
      {
        "elementary_flow_id": "f5bf83404ecd4beadee0049c91f703a1fa85921c",
        "score": 3,
        "unit_exact": true,
        "context_overlap": 2,
        "context_penalty": 1,
        "context_iri_exact": false,
        "unit": "kg",
        "context": [
          "Environmental",
          "Ground",
          "Silvicultural"
        ],
        "context_iri": "https://vocab.brightway.one/flow-contexts/envi-grou-silv"
      }
    ],
    "winning_score": 3,
    "tie_on_top_score": true,
    "source_context_original": [
      "soil",
      "industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_normalized": [
      "Environmental",
      "Ground",
      "Industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_used_for_matching": [
      "Environmental",
      "Ground",
      "Industrial"
    ],
    "source_context_matching_basis": "normalized"
  },
  "provenance": {
    "prov:wasGeneratedBy": "merge_ecoinvent",
    "prov:wasAttributedTo": "brightway-flows",
    "prov:hadPrimarySource": [
      "ecoinvent:3.8:9c706cff-cb82-4207-a589-95896e04dc08",
      "Manganese",
      "",
      "algorithm.lookup_order=cas>ec>label",
      "algorithm.basis=cas:7439-96-5",
      "algorithm.flow_object_candidates=1",
      "algorithm.elementary_candidates=16",
      "algorithm.selector_reason=new-elementary-flow-created",
      "algorithm.score_rule=exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto",
      "algorithm.winning_score=3",
      "algorithm.tie_on_top_score=true"
    ],
    "prov:wasDerivedFrom": "algorithmic_fallback:lookup_order(cas>ec>label);basis(cas:7439-96-5);flow_object_candidates(1);elementary_candidates(16);selector(new-elementary-flow-created);exact-iri-shortcircuit;up-tree-filter;score=(2*unit_exact)+context_overlap-context_penalty+context_iri_exact;contradiction-veto"
  }
}

Keyboard

?
Show or hide this map
/
Focus search
Esc
Close